Gusto vs Heartland Payroll Comparison

Remove All

95% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more

Gusto

Payroll Software

4.4 2,056 user ratings

Get Free Quote

85% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more

Heartland Payroll

Payroll Software

4.4 245 user ratings

Get Free Quote

Papaya Global

Payroll Software

4.5 34 user ratings

Visit Website

OnPay

Payroll Software

4.8 581 user ratings

Visit Website

Overview

Description	Gusto is an all-on-one solution that offers HR, benefits, payroll, and time tracking functionality, all from one centralized platform. Gusto’s HR capabilities include the ability to more efficiently and effectively onboard new hires, to ensure they are getting up-to-speed quickly, settling into the company, and gaining the necessary knowledge. Gusto cuts down on your admin and paperwork –– which also provides benefits in terms of sustainability by enabling your employees to sign forms and contracts, as well as enroll in benefits and your company’s payroll scheme, online. This means you don’t have to print any paper forms. Gusto also enables you and your employees to manage PTO better bu automatically syncing with both your company calendar and your payroll system. You can also send out anonymous surveys to find out how your team is doing, get recommendations on how to improve, and receive feedback on what your employees like and don’t like. As Gusto centralizes your data, you can more easily stay complaint with HR regulations. Read more	Heartland Payroll is a platform that gives users one dedicated representative for all their service-related needs. Users also get on-demand access to HR professionals who provide guidance on industry and state-specific labor laws, respond quickly to important issues, and provide customizable documents. The platform enables users to not only process payroll but also time and attendance. It lets users track hours of their employees' work via manual punches, badges, or biometric technologies. The platform enables users to manage every aspect of paid time off, build and monitor schedules, create reports for labor, exceptions, overtime, absences, and much more. It also helps in sorting workers' compensation. Heartland Payroll uses superior technology and a built-in electronic filing system that ensures users' business safety. It also offers a wide range of reporting capabilities to help companies manage their payroll taxes and stay compliant. Users can easily see all of their withholdings for the year, from social security and health benefits to workers’ compensation and unemployment, using their information hub. Read more	A payroll suite for businesses. Papaya Global is a cloud-based payroll management software that helps multinational businesses manage worldwide payroll, international payments, and contractors. The software comprises vital features, including data security, cost breakdown analysis, records management, and benefits administration. Using a party EoR (employer of record), this software helps users streamline recruiting in multiple duplications and countries and manage payments and classification for foreign and domestic contract workers. This integrated platform provides tools for managing, recruiting, and onboarding when employees are in edge-to-edge solutions. Moreover, Papaya Global alerts the country and staff members for documentation when the review is required. Additionally, managers can automate payroll processes in various currencies and analyze workforce spending on a centralized dashboard. And through a secure portal, workers can attain their payment receipt in their native language. This software allows business teams to meet in compliance by storing employee invoices, documents, forms, and report formats according to the needs of each jurisdiction or country. Papaya Global software follows subscription-based and quotation-based pricing strategies under Payroll, Global, Eor, Contractor Management, And Parallel Intelligence Suite Plans. Read more	OnPay offers growing businesses payroll, HR, and benefits that makes their lives a lot easier. Available in 50 states, it allows employers to run payroll from anywhere, pay employees by direct deposit, debit cards or printed checks, and automate all their tax filings and payments. OnPay even handles all the setup and offers a tax accuracy guarantee. All of OnPay's services are included for a flat monthly fee of $36 plus $4 per employee. Its fee includes unlimited pay runs (and any cancellations), tax filings (including 1099s and W-2s), and best-in-class integrations with QuickBooks, Xero, and top time tracking software. and extends to payroll for organizations like nonprofits, clergy, and agricultural businesses. A full set of HR tools (including self-onboarding, offer letters, and PTO tracking) is also included. When an employer wants to offer more robust benefits, OnPay is a licensed health insurance broker in all 50 states, plus it offers 401(k) and workers' comp plans through seamless integrations. OnPay receives the highest possible ratings from the Motley Fool’s Blueprint and CPA Practice Advisor, an “Excellent” rating from PC Magazine, and the — most importantly — best customer ratings on review sites like Capterra. Read more
Pricing Options	Free Trial Not Available Starts at $39.0.	Free Trial Not Available Heartland Payroll Offers Custom plan.	Free Trial Not Available Starts at $20.0.	Free Trial Available Starts at $40.0.
SW Score & Breakdown	95% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more Features The Feature Score % is calculated using the weighted average method, where core features hold more weight in the final calculation. Read more 100% Reviews 88% Momentum 68% Popularity 98%	85% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more Features The Feature Score % is calculated using the weighted average method, where core features hold more weight in the final calculation. Read more 97% Reviews 78% Momentum 60% Popularity 67%	87% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more Features The Feature Score % is calculated using the weighted average method, where core features hold more weight in the final calculation. Read more 91% Reviews 77% Momentum 64% Popularity 87%	92% SW Score The SW Score ranks the products within a particular category on a variety of parameters, to provide a definite ranking system. Read more Features The Feature Score % is calculated using the weighted average method, where core features hold more weight in the final calculation. Read more 100% Reviews 84% Momentum 61% Popularity 90%
SaaSworthy Awards	# 1 Most Worthy # 1 Highly Rated	Not Available	Not Available	# 2 Highly Rated # 3 Fastest Growing

Features

Total Features	13 Features	12 Features	9 Features	13 Features
Common Features for All	401(k) Tracking Helps to track and manage matters concerning 401(k) that is a retirement savings plan sponsored by an employer. Attendance Tracking Helps to quickly and easily track the attendance Benefits Management Helps in monitoring and managing non-wage compensation given to employees besides their regular salaries or wages. Check Printing Allows previewing and printing standard and customized paychecks Compensation Management Manages employee compensation related data in an organized and automated manner Deductions Management Helps optimizing deductions workflow and assist in calculating various deductions or additions like ESI, PF, integrating leave, performance Direct Deposit Supports direct deposit which is the most popular method for giving paycheques to employees in an electronic form Leave Tracking (Vacation) Assist in keeping track of leave and holidays for easing the payment calculation process Multi-country Supports electronically transfer of payments to employees regardless of the country or state Self Service Portal Provides the employees with a website where they can update their accounts, make bill payments, avail necessary information and other self-help functions Tax Management Management of finances for payment of tax as well as assessing the advance tax liability to pay your tax in time W-2 Preparation Helps electronically preparing the W-2 form that reveals the total gross income of an employee. Wage Garnishment Helps in deducting the amount from an employee's monetary compensation including salary as per a court order to pay off debt + 10 More - Show Less	401(k) Tracking Helps to track and manage matters concerning 401(k) that is a retirement savings plan sponsored by an employer. Attendance Tracking Helps to quickly and easily track the attendance Benefits Management Helps in monitoring and managing non-wage compensation given to employees besides their regular salaries or wages. Check Printing Allows previewing and printing standard and customized paychecks Compensation Management Manages employee compensation related data in an organized and automated manner Deductions Management Helps optimizing deductions workflow and assist in calculating various deductions or additions like ESI, PF, integrating leave, performance Direct Deposit Supports direct deposit which is the most popular method for giving paycheques to employees in an electronic form Leave Tracking (Vacation) Assist in keeping track of leave and holidays for easing the payment calculation process Multi-country Supports electronically transfer of payments to employees regardless of the country or state Self Service Portal Provides the employees with a website where they can update their accounts, make bill payments, avail necessary information and other self-help functions Tax Management Management of finances for payment of tax as well as assessing the advance tax liability to pay your tax in time W-2 Preparation Helps electronically preparing the W-2 form that reveals the total gross income of an employee. Wage Garnishment Helps in deducting the amount from an employee's monetary compensation including salary as per a court order to pay off debt + 9 More - Show Less	401(k) Tracking Helps to track and manage matters concerning 401(k) that is a retirement savings plan sponsored by an employer. Attendance Tracking Helps to quickly and easily track the attendance Benefits Management Helps in monitoring and managing non-wage compensation given to employees besides their regular salaries or wages. Check Printing Allows previewing and printing standard and customized paychecks Compensation Management Manages employee compensation related data in an organized and automated manner Deductions Management Helps optimizing deductions workflow and assist in calculating various deductions or additions like ESI, PF, integrating leave, performance Direct Deposit Supports direct deposit which is the most popular method for giving paycheques to employees in an electronic form Leave Tracking (Vacation) Assist in keeping track of leave and holidays for easing the payment calculation process Multi-country Supports electronically transfer of payments to employees regardless of the country or state Self Service Portal Provides the employees with a website where they can update their accounts, make bill payments, avail necessary information and other self-help functions Tax Management Management of finances for payment of tax as well as assessing the advance tax liability to pay your tax in time W-2 Preparation Helps electronically preparing the W-2 form that reveals the total gross income of an employee. Wage Garnishment Helps in deducting the amount from an employee's monetary compensation including salary as per a court order to pay off debt + 6 More - Show Less	401(k) Tracking Helps to track and manage matters concerning 401(k) that is a retirement savings plan sponsored by an employer. Attendance Tracking Helps to quickly and easily track the attendance Benefits Management Helps in monitoring and managing non-wage compensation given to employees besides their regular salaries or wages. Check Printing Allows previewing and printing standard and customized paychecks Compensation Management Manages employee compensation related data in an organized and automated manner Deductions Management Helps optimizing deductions workflow and assist in calculating various deductions or additions like ESI, PF, integrating leave, performance Direct Deposit Supports direct deposit which is the most popular method for giving paycheques to employees in an electronic form Leave Tracking (Vacation) Assist in keeping track of leave and holidays for easing the payment calculation process Multi-country Supports electronically transfer of payments to employees regardless of the country or state Self Service Portal Provides the employees with a website where they can update their accounts, make bill payments, avail necessary information and other self-help functions Tax Management Management of finances for payment of tax as well as assessing the advance tax liability to pay your tax in time W-2 Preparation Helps electronically preparing the W-2 form that reveals the total gross income of an employee. Wage Garnishment Helps in deducting the amount from an employee's monetary compensation including salary as per a court order to pay off debt + 10 More - Show Less

Technical Details

Organization Types Supported	Freelancers Large Enterprises Medium Business Small Business	Freelancers Large Enterprises Medium Business Small Business	Freelancers Large Enterprises Medium Business Small Business	Freelancers Large Enterprises Medium Business Small Business
Platforms Supported	SaaS/Web/Cloud Mobile - Android Mobile - iOS	SaaS/Web/Cloud Mobile - Android Mobile - iOS	SaaS/Web/Cloud Mobile - Android Mobile - iOS	SaaS/Web/Cloud Mobile - Android Mobile - iOS
Modes of Support	24/7 (Live rep) Business Hours Online	24/7 (Live rep) Business Hours Online	24/7 (Live rep) Business Hours Online	24/7 (Live rep) Business Hours Online

Reviews & Ratings

User Rating	4.4/5 2,056 user ratings	4.4/5 245 user ratings	4.5/5 34 user ratings	4.8/5 581 user ratings
Ratings Distribution	Excellent 68.3% Very Good 19.5% Average 4.1% Poor 1.4% Terrible 6.8%	Excellent 70.3% Very Good 15% Average 5.7% Poor 1.6% Terrible 7.3%	Excellent 76.5% Very Good 8.8% Average 5.9% Poor 2.9% Terrible 5.9%	Excellent 91% Very Good 5.9% Average 0.7% Poor 0.1% Terrible 2.3%
Review Summary	Users appreciate Gusto's user-friendly interface, comprehensive features, and excellent customer support. They find it easy to use, even for those with limited accounting knowledge. Additionally, users value Gusto's ability to help them save time and money through automation and integration with other software. Gusto also receives praise for its mobile app, which allows users to manage payroll and HR tasks on the go. However, some users have mentioned occasional technical glitches and integration issues, and a few have expressed concerns about the cost. Overall, Gusto is a well-received payroll and HR solution that users find efficient, user-friendly, and supportive.	Not Available	Not Available	OnPay is praised for its user-friendly interface, intuitive design, and comprehensive support options. Reviewers highlight the software's ability to streamline payroll processes, including pay runs, tax calculations, and direct deposits. The reporting feature is well-received for its robust insights. Additionally, OnPay's customer service is lauded for its responsiveness, professionalism, and proactive approach in addressing user concerns. However, some users express dissatisfaction with the occasional technical glitches and limited customization options.
	Read All User Reviews	Read All User Reviews	Read All User Reviews	Read All User Reviews

AI-Generated from the text of User Reviews

Pricing

Pricing Options	Free Trial Not Available Starts at $39.0.	Free Trial Not Available Heartland Payroll Offers Custom plan.	Free Trial Not Available Starts at $20.0.	Free Trial Available Starts at $40.0.
Pricing Plans Monthly Plans Annual Plans	Core $39.00 $39.00 per month Complete $39.00 $39.00 per month Concierge $149.00 $149.00 per month	Heartland payroll Custom	Payroll $20.00 $20.00 per user / month Global EOR $770.00 $770.00 per user / month Contractor Management and IC Compliance $25.00 $25.00 per user Payroll Intelligence Suite $250.00 $250.00 per year	OnPay $40.00 $40.00 per month
	View Detailed Pricing	View Detailed Pricing	View Detailed Pricing	View Detailed Pricing

Alternatives

	Justworks 4.7 Based on 971 Ratings Gusto Vs Justworks Paychex Flex 4.1 Based on 3598 Ratings Gusto Vs Paychex Flex QuickBooks Payroll 4.4 Based on 626 Ratings Gusto Vs QuickBooks Payroll Open Payroll NETCHEX	Paychex Flex 4.1 Based on 3598 Ratings Heartland Payroll Vs Paychex Flex ADP Payroll Services Heartland Payroll Vs ADP Payroll Services ADP Workforce Now 4.4 Based on 1871 Ratings Paycom 4.4 Based on 3619 Ratings Heartland Payroll Vs Paycom Gusto 4.4 Based on 4212 Ratings Heartland Payroll Vs Gusto
	View All Gusto Alternatives	View All Heartland Payroll Alternatives