get-free-advice
Clara Icon MEET CLARA - THE AI BEHIND SMARTER SOFTWARE CHOICES
Get Started
/*
Loading...
*/
PrimePay Reviews

User Rating

4.3/5 (Based on 143 Ratings)

Rating Distribution

  • Excellent

    68.5%
  • Very Good

    11.2%
  • Average

    2.1%
  • Poor

    17.5%
  • Terrible

    0.7%

User Sentiments

Responsive Customer Service, Ease of Use, Time Tracking Capabilities, Payroll Accuracy

Lack of Dedicated Support, Untimely Payroll Processing, Poor Reporting Functionality, Outdated User Interface

Do You Use PrimePay?

Write a Review

Review Summary

PrimePay user reviews highlight a mixed experience, with strong praise for customer service often coupled with concerns about processing services and technology. Dedicated representatives and prompt responses earn high marks, while users report issues with timely processing, system updates, and reporting capabilities. The platform's user-friendliness is a point of contention, with some finding it intuitive while others experience difficulty in navigating specific features. Overall, PrimePay is acknowledged for its value in managing payroll and HR tasks, but improvements in technology and system consistency are desired by many users.

Pros

  • PrimePay offers userfriendly software and excellent customer service.
  • The system is easy to use and makes payroll processing a breeze.
  • The interface is intuitive and easy to learn, with robust functionality.

Cons

  • Customer support response times can be slow, particularly via email.
  • Some users have reported issues with the timekeeping features.
  • The system may not always be as intuitive as desired.

AI-Generated from the text of User Reviews

Reviews
VI

Verified User in Insurance

February 20, 2026 Source: G2.com
Competitive Pricing That Stands Out Among COBRA Administrators
What do you like best about PrimePay?The pricing is competitive when compared to other cobra administrators.What do you dislike about PrimePay?The support has gone downhill in the last two years. There are seldom issues but when there are it can take weeks to resolve.What problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?Cobra administration
Read more
IY

Irma Y

February 19, 2026 Source: G2.com
Makes Employee Departures Compliance Easy and Stress-Free
What do you like best about PrimePay?Not having to remember or guess what proper compliance is needed when an employee departs from your business.What do you dislike about PrimePay?The downside is only in the beginning of using their services. Once you are familiar with how the site works, things are a breeze.What problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?Giving me the benefit of having a personal assistant that you know is going to get what is need right the first time.
Read more
VM

Verified User in Machinery

February 18, 2026 Source: G2.com
User-Friendly Payroll with Knowledgeable, Professional Support
What do you like best about PrimePay?It is user friendly, and the technicians are always professional and knowledgeable when I need assistance. I can easily break down pay by regular hours, overtime hours, PTO, sick pay, commission, holidays, etc. It is also easy to add deductions and employees.What do you dislike about PrimePay?There really is not anything I dislike. We are a very small company, so the features we use are perfect for us.What problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?We have always used PrimePay while I have been employed, but I cannot imagine calculating any portion of payroll, especially payroll taxes, without PrimePay.
Read more
VM

Verified User in Non-Profit Organization Management

February 18, 2026 Source: G2.com
OBRA Automatic COBRA Management—Set It and Forget It
What do you like best about PrimePay?Automatic. I don't ever have to think about COBRA.What do you dislike about PrimePay?Nothing - would not change anything with the COBRA process.What problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?C
Read more
VC

Verified User in Construction

February 17, 2026 Source: G2.com
Easy to use with comprehensive offerings.
What do you like best about PrimePay?Ease of use. The interface is mostly self-explanatory.What do you dislike about PrimePay?Their tax department could be more knowledgeable and helpful.What problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?I don't have any problems at this time.
Read more
ML

Mike L

February 17, 2026 Source: G2.com
Simple to Use with Prompt, Reliable Support
What do you like best about PrimePay?It’s simple to use, and the support is very prompt whenever I need it.What do you dislike about PrimePay?Make it simpler for the user to create and use their own reportsWhat problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?Filing our tax returns.
Read more
CS

Carol S

February 12, 2026 Source: G2.com
Reliable Support with Easy Setup
What do you like best about PrimePay?I really appreciate how someone always answers the phone and gets the answers I need, showing PrimePay's customer support is both professional and reliable. The initial setup was super easy, and they always come through for me. I can't think of anything to complain about, which is great.What do you dislike about PrimePay?NothingWhat problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?I use PrimePay for payroll and FSA benefits. They solve payroll problems and their phone support is professional and reliable, always helping me get the answers I need.
Read more
VA

Verified User in Accounting

September 30, 2025 Source: G2.com
Timekeeping Quick & Responsive implementation
What do you like best about PrimePay?.Flexibility in pricing and modules, that allow clients to pick and choose how much they're spending for the services they needWhat do you dislike about PrimePay?Lack of control over certain aspects of the time keeping & payroll systemWhat problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?Payroll &
Read more
DM

Daniel M

September 30, 2025 Source: G2.com
Denton Senft and his group have been great to work with for several of our clients.
What do you like best about PrimePay?The level of responsiveness has been great.What do you dislike about PrimePay?Nothing in particular is coming to mind.What problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?helping to outsource payroll for clients
Read more
LK

Laura K

September 8, 2025 Source: G2.com
My experience with Gretchen Berger was above and beyond exptectation.
What do you like best about PrimePay?PrimePay is extremely easy to use. From the minute I learned about PrimePay from Gretchen Berger, I knew I was in great hands. The cost of the sowftware blew away the competition. I would highly recommend PrimePay to other companies.What do you dislike about PrimePay?Absolutely nonthing. Everything is wonderful.What problems is PrimePay solving and how is that benefiting you?Time management and efficiency. PrimePay does all the calculations and runs a very smooth payroll process. It is benefiting me, by helping me to run payroll and save money in the process.
Read more

FTC Disclosure

SaaSworthy may receive compensation from some vendors featured on this page. This does not influence our editorial evaluation or ratings. [email protected]

We understand SaaS better

SaaSworthy helps stakeholders choose the right SaaS platform based on detailed product information, unbiased reviews, SW score and recommendations from the active community.

icon

Buyers

Looking for the right SaaS

We can help you choose the best SaaS for your specific requirements. Our in-house experts will assist you with their hand-picked recommendations.

icon

Makers

Want more customers?

Our experts will research about your product and list it on SaaSworthy for FREE.

Get Listed